REVIEW OF ...
Sprawling from Grace, Driven To Madness
Movie (Documentary) Released: 2008
This 'Sprawling from Grace, Driven To Madness' review written by Mark Jeantheau, Grinning Planet.
A lot of the topics Sprawling from Grace, Driven To Madness—peak oil, sprawl, unsustainable trends—have been covered in other peak oil films, though they are nonetheless explained very well here. The film correctly identifies flow rate, not total reserves, as the critical factor to consider when looking at where we stand with oil supplies. Sprawling from Grace also makes the observation that, among Western nations, the United States has a uniquely high level of sprawl, which will mean unique energy problems and social challenges in the coming oil-constrained future.
The film features a particularly good review of why alternatives will fail to arrive in time to avert a future fossil-fuels crisis, as well as an exploration of the denial psychology that afflicts most of our politicians and most of the public. James Howard Kunstler sums it up wonderfully: "If America could harness the energy from blowing smoke up it's own ass, we could solve the energy problem."
Though Sprawling from Grace has many of the familiar faces (like Kunstler) making many familiar pronouncements, it also presents some new interviewees and gives a fresh treatment to some of the angles. ASPO-USA co-founder Randy Udall offers the trenchant insight that "energy is wealth." Wonksters like Michael Dukakis and Bill Clinton, as well as hands-on urban thinkers like the mayor of Charlotte, North Carolina, all help fill in the political angle on the sprawl problem without getting into a blame game.
Though the movie is a clear critique of sprawl, it is actually sympathetic to the story of how we got here: Living outside the city was appealing and it was affordable for a time, so the gravitation towards it was understandable. The question is, now what?
The movie speculates that "our love affair with the car is fading." That seems more like wishful thinking rather than tires-on-the-ground observation. At least here in the United States, the average driver still loves their car and the fabulous degree of personal mobility it enables. What they hate is the snarly traffic and rude drivers; the never-ending maintenance and gougey repair bills; and, of course, the high price of gas when it spikes. The bottom line is, though, most Americans cannot imagine how their lives would run without a personal automobile. And to be fair, our current spread-out living arrangement makes that hard to envision.
But Sprawling from Grace argues that it no longer matters whether our first choice is a transition back to walkable communities, expanded mass transit in cities, and rail-based transportation networks. Without cheap, abundant oil, it's our only choice.
In the end, the film is convincing in its assertion that the suburban way of life cannot and, ultimately, will not go on. Its focus on workable urban solutions saves Sprawling from Grace from being "just another peak oil movie."
One minor complaint is that the text giving people's positions/titles was so small that even on a 46" TV it was nearly impossible to read. Hey, I know I have 50-year-old eyes, but sheesh!
One might be tempted to question whether the economic mess and future energy constraints make it rather unrealistic to think that we can undo 50 years' worth of sprawling infrastructure and rebuild it in a manner than will work on a much more limited energy budget in the future. That proposition seems especially daunting when one realizes that few of our leaders offer more than token support for sustainability—"growth" is still the mantra found in every politician's speeches—and that the vast majority of the public still does not see how fundamentally unsustainable our current direction is.
But we should at least start with an honest discussion why it's important to try to re-envision, reengineer, and re-build. Sprawling from Grace provides a good starting point for that conversation, helping us understand the problem and the solutions, arming with insight and facts so that we can make apt changes in our own lives and push our leaders to choose a new path. The "new urbanist" lifestyle will not be for everyone, but many more people will be living that way in the future by necessity.
Check out 'Sprawling from Grace, Driven To Madness' at
Liner notes for 'Sprawling from Grace, Driven To Madness': Tagline: We've become the oil tribe!
Categories: Peak Oil, Suburban Sprawl.
A film by David M. Edwards.
Runtime: 82 minutes
FREE AUDIO CLIPS
Grinning Planet also has audio . . .
Challenging Our Own Beliefs —
01 May 2013 —
KMO and science fiction author, futurist, and contrarian David Brin discuss a range of themes in post-apocalyptic and dystopian fiction. Brin also opines on the need to be contrarian and to challenge our own beliefs. As human civilization faces a transition from smart animals to beings that wield god-like powers in real time with no do-overs, we must overcome our tendency toward self-deception, factionalism, and righteous indignation.
Go to page |
Quirks & Quarks
Better Bacterial Biofuels Through Genetic Engineering? —
27 Apr 2013 —
As the failings of current biofuels become more obvious, the strategies to find a truly successful, high-net-energy biofuel continues. Professor John Love discusses efforts to genetically engineer microbes that will more efficiently convert simple sugars into petro-identical go-juice for our vehicles.
Go to page |
All biofuels are destined to fail, if only for the rarely discussed but obvious reason that they steal resources from biological processes that are essential to a sustainable global ecosystem.)
Stealing From the Future —
24 April 2013 —
Mark Robinowitz of the Oil Empire web site notes that earth is over its carrying capacity, regardless of which problem—climate change, peak oil, water supplies, etc.—you wish to discuss. In this "peak everything" era, we're using everything as fast as we possibly can, with nothing but economists' assurances that there will be the same level of abundance in the future. Our most serious problem is "peak denial"—the general public is rejecting reality. He explains why the declarations of some environmentalists that extraction technologies have trumped peak oil are wrong, and he laments that climate change has come to dominate the entire discussion about sustainability. In particular, he comments that the typical environmentalist's position that we can solve climate though economic methods within the infinite growth paradigm is hopelessly wrong.
Go to page |
CLICKS ON OUR ADS AND PURCHASES VIA OUR AMAZON LINKS HELP SUPPORT THIS FREE SITE... THANKS!
"...More important than the deficit, more important then healthcare—more important than anything—we have got to do something about our energy strategy. Because if we permit the climate to continue to warm at an unsustainable rate, and if we keep on doing what we're doing until we're out of oil and we haven't made the transition, then it's inconceivable to me that our children and grandchildren will be able to maintain the American way of life and that the world won't be much fuller of resource-based wars of all kinds."
— former president Bill Clinton, speaking in Sprawling From Grace; Driven To Madness